A national medical services provider wanted to grow by buying smaller companies in markets it planned to enter. I represented the buyer. The target was a smaller company that provided locum tenens staffing, and the asset my client wanted was its book of 20 client contracts.

Contract due diligence meant reading every one of them, and I flagged every problem in each. No two matched. Each had different terms, different durations, and different jurisdiction and venue clauses. One required any lawsuit over the contract to be filed in the Bahamas, and my client was based in Delaware. Some contracts were about to lapse. Others already had.

Then came the biggest problem. None of the contracts could be assigned without consent. Every client those contracts served would have had to agree to the sale before my client could step in. The asset was the contracts, and the seller couldn’t actually deliver them. I recommended that my client skip the deal and find a better one.

Revenue Is Not Governance

A seller’s revenue tells you nothing about how it runs. That company had 20 client relationships and still had no standard for what it signed. Inconsistent contracts are a red flag. They tell you the seller ran an ad hoc shop, where whoever landed the client wrote the terms. Before you sign, ask a simple question. Has this company kept up its contract discipline and corporate governance, or has it improvised for years?

You can usually see the answer during diligence. Watch how the seller produces documents. Watch whether the same clause reads the same way twice. A seller who can’t explain its own contracts is telling you what you’ll inherit.

The Mess Comes With You

Most buyers treat a seller’s messy contracts as a diligence problem. You find it, price it, and move on. The real risk is that the mess comes with you. The problems show up in diligence if you look for them. If you close without fixing them, they become yours on day one.

Picture that deal closing. My client would have owned 20 contracts with 20 sets of rules, renewal dates scattered across the calendar, and a possible lawsuit in a foreign venue. From that day, the clock starts. Give yourself 90 days to bring every acquired contract onto your own terms, or the seller’s habits become your habits. Here are the five steps I use, and each one comes straight from that deal.

Five Steps for Contract Due Diligence

1. Inventory

Read every contract and put the key terms on one page. Capture term, duration, renewal, governing law, and venue for each one. I did this for all 20, and that one page showed how little the contracts had in common. This week, build a one-page contract summary for your top acquisition target.

2. Playbook

Measure each contract against your own standard terms. The Bahamas clause only stands out if you know what your terms are supposed to say. After closing, the same playbook becomes the tool that moves acquired contracts onto your paper. This week, write down your required venue, governing law, and assignment terms.

3. Consent

Check every contract for limits on assignment and change of control, and list each counterparty who must agree to the transfer. In my deal, that single finding meant the seller couldn’t deliver the asset it was selling. This week, flag every contract in a target’s book that needs consent to transfer.

4. Clock

Map which contracts have lapsed, which are about to, and when the rest renew. A contract that expires next quarter is worth less than its revenue suggests. Some of the contracts in my deal had already run out, which meant part of the asset no longer existed. This week, put every expiration date from your target on one calendar.

5. Walk-Away Line

Set your deal breakers before diligence starts, and take them to the board. Once a team falls in love with a deal, the problems start to look smaller than they are. My recommendation to skip that deal was the most valuable advice in the whole process. This week, write three conditions that would make you walk away from your next deal.

Where Your Next Deal Breaks

I’ve practiced law for 30 years. I spent six years as outside general counsel to a publicly traded company, and I’ve advised the boards of two public companies. That work taught me to read past the revenue and treat contract due diligence as the real test of what a buyer gets. In that staffing deal, the honest answer was not enough, so I told my client to walk away.

So here’s my question for you. If you bought a company tomorrow, how many different sets of contract terms would you inherit?

If you’re building a company through acquisitions and want to compare notes on governance that holds up as you grow, I’d welcome the conversation. You can reach me here. 

Keep Reading

This article is general information and not legal advice. Get your own attorney.